Who Are We?

Nestled in the heart of Pine Island, Spots Ice Cream is more than just an ice cream shop; it's a welcoming gathering place where community and celebration thrive. Aimee, a passionate realtor, and her friend Sarah, a former ice cream shop owner, envisioned a space for neighbors and friends to connect and create lasting memories over delicious treats. Their love for this vibrant community inspired them to open Spots Ice Cream, where everyone feels like they found their spot.

We proudly serve Yoders Ice Cream, sourced from the Amish community in Sarasota. Known for its rich, creamy texture and an incredible variety of flavors, Yoders offers everything from classic vanilla and rich chocolate to unique options like Blueberry Cheesecake and Salted Caramel Praline. Each carefully crafted combination is designed to satisfy every sweet tooth and ensure your visit is memorable.

We invite you to find your "spot" at Spots Ice Cream. Come and pin your “spot” on one of our many maps in our shop. With comfortable seating and a friendly staff ready to serve you, we aim to provide an experience that keeps you coming back. We hope that each visit will create new memories with family and friends. So whether you’re a local or just passing through, stop by and treat yourself to a taste of community and unforgettable ice cream. We look forward to “Spotting” you!